Skip to content

Speaking Task 5 samples

CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading samples

Compare original NorthPrep comparing and persuading responses at CLB 6, CLB 8, and CLB 10. Study how the same task becomes clearer, more developed, and more precise across levels.

Original NorthPrep practice samples

Speaking Task 5: Comparing and Persuading

Prepare 60sRespond 60s

Open a prompt, compare the same task at three levels, and focus on the decisions behind the response instead of memorizing sentences. These are original NorthPrep practice samples, not real CELPIP questions or official answers.

Sample question 01

Your friend has moved to Ottawa and is choosing between two ways to commute to work. Option A is a monthly transit pass with unlimited bus and light-rail travel. Option B is buying a used compact car with insurance, fuel, parking, and maintenance costs. Persuade your friend to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the monthly transit pass. A car would make late-night trips and errands easier, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it gives you a fixed monthly cost, avoids parking and repair worries, and lets you learn the city before making a major purchase. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the monthly transit pass, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to use transit for six months and cover occasional gaps with a taxi, rental, or car-share.

Sample question 02

Your sister in Calgary wants to improve her fitness and is choosing between two options. Option A is a low-cost community-centre membership with a pool, gym, and group classes. Option B is buying home exercise equipment and following online workouts. Persuade your sister to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the community-centre membership. Home workouts save travel time and are convenient on busy days, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it offers variety, scheduled classes, staff support, and social accountability without a large upfront cost. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the community-centre membership, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to start with a three-month membership and add only simple home equipment later. This way, you are not taking a large risk, and you can see whether the choice works in real life.

Sample question 03

Your coworker in Toronto is deciding where to hold a small retirement celebration. Option A is a private room at a restaurant with a set menu. Option B is a potluck in the office meeting room. Persuade your coworker to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the restaurant's private room. The office potluck would be cheaper, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that the set menu creates a predictable budget, staff handle service and clean-up, and the setting feels special enough for speeches and photographs. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the restaurant's private room, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to choose a modest lunch menu and confirm attendance before paying a deposit.

Sample question 04

Your cousin in Winnipeg is choosing between two apartments. Option A is a newer unit far from work with lower rent and in-suite laundry. Option B is an older unit near work with higher rent but a short walk to the office and grocery stores. Persuade your cousin to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the older apartment near work. The newer unit has lower rent and more attractive features, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that the walkable location saves commuting time and transportation costs every day, especially during a Winnipeg winter. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the older apartment near work, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to inspect the heating, windows, plumbing, and maintenance record before signing.

Sample question 05

Your friend in Halifax wants to take a short professional course. Option A is an evening classroom course at a local college with fixed weekly sessions. Option B is a self-paced online course that can be completed from home. Persuade your friend to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the evening classroom course. The online course is more flexible and avoids travel, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that fixed sessions create accountability, questions can be answered immediately, and classmates provide discussion and professional contacts. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the evening classroom course, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to accept the temporary schedule because completing the course matters more than maximum flexibility.

Sample question 06

Your manager in Edmonton is choosing how to recognize employees at the end of a busy project. Option A is giving everyone a small cash bonus. Option B is holding a paid team day with lunch and a group activity. Persuade your manager to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the cash bonus. A team day could create shared memories, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it is useful in different personal situations, avoids pressure to socialize, and directly connects the reward to the extra work. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the cash bonus, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to pair the bonus with a modest catered lunch during paid working hours.

Sample question 07

Your neighbour in Surrey wants to reduce household food waste. Option A is joining a weekly community compost collection program for a small fee. Option B is buying a backyard compost bin and managing it independently. Persuade your neighbour to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the weekly collection program. A backyard bin can create free compost, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it is clean, consistent, easy to maintain, and can process a wider range of scraps without odours or pests. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the weekly collection program, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to use the service for food scraps and keep a small pile only for leaves and garden waste.

Sample question 08

Your friend in Montreal is planning a weekend trip to Quebec City. Option A is travelling by intercity bus, which is inexpensive and arrives downtown. Option B is renting a car, which offers flexibility but adds fuel, parking, and insurance costs. Persuade your friend to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the intercity bus. A rental car would offer more freedom outside the city, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it arrives downtown, avoids parking and winter-driving stress, and matches a short trip focused on central attractions. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the intercity bus, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to book early and use local transit or an occasional taxi for any distant stop.

Sample question 09

Your parents in Brampton want to replace an old refrigerator. Option A is a basic energy-efficient model with fewer features and a lower price. Option B is a more expensive smart refrigerator with a screen, app connection, and extra compartments. Persuade your parents to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the basic energy-efficient refrigerator. The smart model looks modern and has convenient compartments, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that it focuses spending on reliable cooling, lower electricity use, simpler repairs, and features they will actually use. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the basic energy-efficient refrigerator, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to compare capacity, warranty, noise, and local service instead of paying for a screen.

Sample question 10

Your friend in Saskatoon has been offered two volunteer roles. Option A is helping weekly at a food bank with fixed duties. Option B is joining an occasional city-event volunteer list with different assignments throughout the year. Persuade your friend to choose one option.

Compare CLB 6, 8, and 10 answers

CLB 6 model answer

I think you should choose the weekly food-bank role. The city-event list provides more variety and flexibility, but the other choice will probably be better for your regular needs. The main reason is that regular service builds stronger skills, relationships, responsibility, and a deeper understanding of community needs. This is important because the decision will affect your time, money, and routine, not only the first few days. You should also think about how often you will truly use the special advantages of the other option. Sometimes an option looks exciting, but the extra cost or effort continues every month. With the weekly food-bank role, the plan is simpler and easier to manage. You can still change later if your situation is different. My suggestion is to make the food bank the main commitment and add one or two special events for variety.

Put the comparison into practice

Write or speak your own answer next.

Practise this Speaking task with AI feedback

01

Study decisions, not impressive sentences

Read each prompt first and decide how you would organize it. Then compare your plan with the sample: identify the opening decision, the order of the main points, the specific supporting details, and the closing move. Those choices transfer to a new prompt; copied wording usually does not.

  • Name the job of each section of the answer.
  • Connect every example to the task purpose.
  • Notice how transitions express real relationships.
  • Retell the response in different words before moving on.

02

Why memorizing a model answer can hurt

A memorized answer may sound polished but fail to address the person, scene, choice, or problem in front of you. It also makes recovery difficult when a prompt changes. Build a small set of flexible structures—advice steps, scene routes, clue-based predictions, listener-focused reasons—and fill them with details from the actual task.

03

Fit your development to the clock

The 90-second tasks allow more development, so a strong response can support two or three points with examples. The 60-second tasks reward a quicker opening and selective detail. Task 5 also includes a separate choice stage before preparation for the persuasive response. Use the timing labels on every sample to rehearse a realistic plan.

04

Compare your recording with evidence

After practising in NorthPrep, listen to your recording before reading the model again. Check whether you completed the task, organized ideas, developed useful detail, and finished clearly. AI-assisted feedback can add observations about relevance, language, and delivery, but it is a practice aid—not an official assessment or guaranteed score.

Questions learners ask

Short, honest answers

Use these answers to shape a realistic practice plan and understand what NorthPrep can—and cannot—do.

Are these real CELPIP exam questions or official answers?

No. Every prompt and model answer on this page is original NorthPrep practice content. The samples follow the eight task types and timings but do not reproduce secure exam material, official answers, or third-party content.

Should I memorize these Speaking answers?

No. Study how each answer selects, orders, and develops ideas. Then close the sample and respond to a fresh prompt using your own details and natural language.

Does the estimated CLB label predict my exam result?

No. The label describes the standard the sample is designed to illustrate. It is not an official rating, a score for your response, or a prediction of future performance.

Why does Task 5 show an extra timing stage?

Task 5 includes time to choose between options, followed by preparation and a timed persuasive response. The sample card shows all three stages so the practice structure is clear.

Does viewing this page use AI or record my voice?

No. This is a static public study page with pre-written original samples. Recording and optional AI-assisted feedback are available only after you choose to enter NorthPrep Speaking practice.

Put the guide into practice

Build your next focused session.

Practise Speaking